Skip to content
Image shows a person's torso from behind, wearing multi-coloured t-shirt and rucksack with 'Stop the harm' messages on fabric pinned to it.

Care as a Complex, Adaptive Ecosystem

What makes social care a complex adaptive ecosystem and how can understanding this help improve care outcomes for all?

Viewing social care as an ecosystem means recognising it is a complex, adaptive, system, featuring ‘emergent’ outcomes (that are hard to control, but not random) and ‘episodic’ changes (responses to past events, internal ‘feedback loops’ and external ‘shocks’ that may lead to tipping points and change).

What’s distinctive about our approach?

  • We focus on local level arrangements, recognising these are embedded in and linked to other systems.
  • We focus on the wider support in people’s lives, not only publicly-funded, statutory services.

What are the advantages of a systems approach?

  • In theory, systems adapt to their environment; if they can’t, in the end they cease to exist. Some variants of ‘best fit’ to current care ecosystem conditions may be ‘suboptimal’ for some groups. We explore who is affected and how this could change.
  • A systems approach encourages experimentation and learning. Practitioners can be helped to work with complexity to deliver positive change, without feeling overwhelmed or disempowered.
  • It can also foster new thinking about accountability and shift collective thinking away from feeling ‘nothing we can do can make the changes needed’.

Studying UK local and national systems, we focus on:

  • Variations in local care ecosystem stability and effectiveness. We look at market stability, user outcomes, access to information and support, workforce retention, and ask, ‘Can we identify common system features that enable ‘best fit’ to support sustainability, equity and wellbeing?’
  • Implementation of care legislation. New laws have often been poorly implemented. How can this be improved? Complexity insights highlight that policy implementation has to involve more than ‘pulling a lever’ and expecting change to happen.
  • Supporting local actors to shape their strategies, we use insights about complex adaptive systems to help those involved reduce tendencies to feel overwhelmed or fatalistic.
  • Major reforms of care systems, including the Integrated Care Systems designed to bring health and social care together. We aim to map and understand the effects of these changes in real time.

A flourishing social care ecosystem

An ecosystem is a metaphor from nature which we often use in social science when talking about something which is complex and interlinked, and where no one is control of the whole thing.

Here we show our visual representation of a flourishing social care ecosystem, drawn by the artist Laura Brodrick (Home – Think Big Picture). It’s developed from the idea that a flourishing system has activity both above the soil line (visible) and below the soil line (invisible).

Things like care homes and hospitals are the visible part of the system – a bit like the mammals and birds that we see in nature. The invisible parts are all the small community activities which aren’t necessarily thought of as part of social care but are like the microorganisms that make the soil rich and fertile. These are the coffee mornings, choirs, sports clubs, dance groups, faith organisations, family and neighbourhood networks which help people to have purpose and meaning.

We need both the visible and the invisible for a flourishing social care ecosystem. When one part isn’t working well it overloads the other and we end up with a degraded ecosystem, like a barren landscape where nothing grows.

In our research for the Centre for Care we are looking at what characteristics of local social care ecosystems lead to flourishing. We explore whether the features of some local systems make them more likely to be degraded and failing, and how we can support flourishing everywhere.

Hand drawn illustration showing the visible and invisible parts of the care ecosystem. The visible parts of the ecosystem are shown in the top half of the image, the word ‘Visible’ appears above a tree. Characters in care settings appear with various buildings. The following text headings are also visible in the top half of the image, ‘Statutory’, ‘Care Home’, ‘services at home’, ‘Emergency services’, ‘Primary care’, ‘New services’, ‘HOSPITAL’, ‘REHAB’ and ‘Care providers’. The invisible parts of the ecosystem and shown in the bottom half of the image, the word ‘Invisible’ appears underground, below tree roots. Characters in care settings appear with various icons synonymous with social and wellbeing activities. The following text headings are also visible in the bottom half of the image, ‘Community’, ‘Community centre’, ‘School’, ‘Advice’ and ‘drop in’.

Commentary on Care as a Complex, Adaptive Ecosystem

Commentary pieces relating to Care as a Complex, Adaptive Ecosystem

Recent Publications

Members

The Care as a Complex, Adaptive Ecosystem team is led by Professor Catherine Needham at the University of Birmingham.

Catherine Needham profile picture
Catherine Needham Co-Investigator, University of Birmingham
Emily Burn profile picture
Emily Burn Researcher, University of Birmingham